Is a Metal or Wooden Swing Better?

Choosing between a metal swing set and a wooden swing set boils down to your preference and playground needs, since each material has its advantages and disadvantages. To help you find the right swing set that fits your playground, let’s explore the different characteristics that each material can offer.

Comparing Durability: Metal vs. Wooden Swings

It is important for the chosen swing set for kids to last many years to ensure maximum enjoyment and uninterrupted fun. When it comes to durability, the metal swing set might have the upper hand. 

Metal swing sets can last from 15 to 20 years for solid steel types, while the industrial-grade can exceed 30 years as needed, depending on the thickness and quality of the metal used, the protective coating, and the maintenance. Additional features that aid in its durability include:

• Higher resistance to rot, insects, and weathering
• Won’t splinter or crack easily
• Can withstand the weight of multiple children playing at the same time
• Maintains stability under extreme conditions

Wooden swing sets can last from 10 to more than 20 years, depending on the wood quality, the protective treatments, and the maintenance. Some durability-related benefits of wooden swing sets include: 

• Resistance to weather conditions with hardwood like cedar, redwood, and teak
• Natural resistance through oils and tannins against rot, decay, and insects
• Treatments like sealants, paints, and stains can naturally increase longevity

Safety Considerations of Metal and Wooden Swings

It is important to take precautions to ensure that children can play safely and without worries. In terms of safety, wooden swing sets win by a small margin.

Metal Swing Sets

• Heat: Hot metal can burn skin, so heat-resistant coatings and shaded areas are needed to minimize this risk.
• Rust: Rust can weaken the structure and pose potential injuries, requiring frequent checking and replacement of rusted parts.
• Sharp Edges: Inspection of joints and connections should be observed daily to prevent pinch points and sharp edges.
• Connection Parts: Regular examination of tightness of screws and bolts as well as the smoothness of moving parts like S-hooks and bearings is needed.

Wooden Swing Sets

• Splinters: Rough areas and splinters can develop over time, these spots need regular sanding.
• Wood Decay: Moisture and rotten wood can break the swing, so regular treatment and proper drainage could combat these possible damages.
• Insect Damage: Termites and carpenter ants can weaken the play equipment, so treatment or replacement of affected parts is immediate.
• Wear and Tear: Loose screws due to wood shrinkage and wood cracks should be monitored and changed as needed.

Maintenance Requirements for Metal and Wooden Swings

Maintenance plays an important role in increasing the lifespan and durability of both swing sets. Both types of swing sets require regular inspections and periodic cleaning in general.

The key maintenance tip for the metal swing set’s longevity is rust prevention. Rust can be addressed by applying regular rust-resisting paint and coating, as it is the swing set’s top weakness. Additional measures, including lubrication of the moving parts, fastening of the screws and bolts, and regular touch-ups, will help maintain the beloved metallic play equipment.

Wood swing sets require higher maintenance than metal swing sets, yet they can return the investment of long life with proper preservation. Sealing and staining are the key requirements for combating UV rays, insects, moisture, and rotting. These cherished swing sets can also live longer through further processes, such as sanding, pest control, and minor repairs for damaged and weakened signs.

Aesthetic and Design Differences: Metal vs. Wooden Swings

Each material offers a certain appeal and customization features that cannot be replicated by the other.

Metal swing sets carry a modern and sleek design with a minimalistic and industrial feel. They can be customized with colorful powder-coated finishes and various frame styles. They can also incorporate geometric and intricate patterns with smooth surfaces, but are limited to the manufacturer's designs. Often part of larger playground structures, this play equipment is a great highlight for contemporary backyards or large playground settings.

Wooden swing sets opt for a natural and rustic look. Its timeless appeal showcases wooden craftsmanship and more room for customization compared to metal swing sets. These swing sets feature ergonomic designs and are often combined with playhouses and forts. The natural wood grain texture and wood color tones can stimulate users’ tactile and visual interests, making them the perfect touch for residential or intimate settings.

Cost and Value: Choosing Between Metal and Wooden Swings

Considering the practical characteristics of each material, it is also important to factor in the costs and the long-term value that each swing set can provide.

Metal Swing Sets

• Estimated Equipment Costs: A simple single swing can start at $80, while elaborate commercial models with more swing seats can go from $1,000 to more than $4,000. They are generally cheaper than their wooden counterparts.
• Installation Costs: Metal swing sets feature lower labor costs due to easier assembly. Only the larger models may require professional installation.
• Resale Value: If maintained properly, they can be easy to resell, but with lower value. They tend to depreciate quickly and raise safety concerns due to used equipment.
• Maintenance Costs: Metal swing sets feature lower maintenance costs due to less frequent upkeep.
• Long-term Value: Durability with long lifespan and fewer repairs and replacements over time.

Wooden Swings Sets

• Estimated Equipment Costs: The starting value of wooden swing sets is $100 and can go from $1,500 and above, depending on the customization and wood quality materials.
• Installation Costs: Their weight may require more shipping costs, and their installation process may require more time and expertise.
• Resale Value: Wooden swings have higher resale value than metal swing sets, especially if they are custom or handcrafted sets, which makes them more appealing to the market.
• Maintenance Costs: Wooden swings require frequent maintenance which adds to long-term costs, but this contributes to the swings’ longevity.
• Long-term Value: Their timeless appeal, durability, and high resale value allow them to be a worthwhile investment for any playset.

Whether you choose a metal or wooden swing set, both options offer great opportunities for outdoor play and will be a beloved highlight of the shared playing space for the children. The best swing set that you can get depends on your preference and current budget. Playground Equipment is here to help you find the best swing set to fit your needs today.

Learn About the Author

Kim Hart

Kimberly Hart, a native of Indianapolis, is a dedicated mother of two and a passionate writer specializing in topics such as active play, healthy lifestyles, and children's activities; she ensures her kids' health and safety through various sports and adventures. In addition to her role as a main content contributor for PlaygroundEquipment.com, she also spends her spare time volunteering and working as a life coach, helping individuals achieve their fitness goals.

---

Kim on Facebook
Kim on X (formerly Twitter)